A deluded Wall Street threatens the world economy
March 17, 2008 - 0:0
If you'd been in Volare restaurant in downtown Chicago on Monday night, you would not have thought a U.S. recession was imminent; the place was packed, as, earlier, was most of Michigan Avenue, the principal shopping street, despite the freezing winds.
But that was before Friday as news spread of the collapse of Bear Stearns, America's fifth largest investment bank. A mounting financial crisis threatens to undermine the economy that supports, among many others, the clientele of Volare. The United States is about to be trashed by perhaps the greediest, most arrogant, self-deluding financial class in the country's history.It is an epic tragedy whose ramifications are bound to impact on Britain and the rest of the world, beginning with the sanguine economic assumptions - of only the mildest of economic slowdowns - that underpinned Alistair Darling's Budget forecasts last week. But whether in Britain or America, politicians and policy-makers seem frozen into inactivity (with the honorable exception of the U.S. Federal Reserve, America's central bank). Messrs Brown and Darling echo President Bush and U.S. Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson; as little as possible must be done to regulate or impede the operation of the titans of Wall Street and the City, whatever their recklessness. Even Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama, slugging it out for the Democratic presidential nomination, are happier to talk about the threat to American jobs from foreign trade than the mortal threat constituted by an out-of-control and broken financial system.
Yet to blame foreign trade for America's ills is both stupid and wrong. The untold story of our times is of U.S. industry not just holding the line but expanding production, a phenomenon gathering pace as the dollar plunges on world markets, promoting super U.S. competitiveness. American brands and companies increasingly populate the world top 100 and the U.S. invests stunning sums on its knowledge economy base -- software, universities and R&D.
Britain spends proportionally half as much while our exports and industrial base languish. We are much more vulnerable than even the Americans to the impact of falling house prices and contracting credit, though you would never guess it from the way policy is made.
For the U.S. to put its success at risk through protectionism, the stance taken by both Clinton and Obama, while indulging Wall Street is mad. The heart of Keynesian economics was never tax and spend; it was the warning from the greatest economist of the 20th century that a financial system based on free-market principles inevitably destabilized the health and stability of capitalism. Keynes knew his ideas would be contested to the last because he threatened the orthodoxies of laissez faire and the fortunes of the financiers. So it is proving again. For make no mistake -- the global economy is under threat.
It is the slump in American property prices that has prompted the collapse of trust in Wall Street. And the chief reason property prices are falling is an epidemic of repossessions caused because banks lent to poor, uncreditworthy borrowers. Then they disappeared, selling off the debts.
The Americans have invented a system with no commitment, trust or long-term human relationships and the result is mayhem. For the banks, there was a glorious byproduct. They could borrow to a stunning degree because they had, allegedly, spread their risk. Bear Stearns had $11.8bn of capital and $395bn of debt. When things are going well, it is 'leverage' like this that creates the volume of business that generates incredible bonuses for their executives. When things go badly, the bank simply goes bust. .
The unresolved question is a humdinger. How big is the void between all the debt and the actual, slipping, value of the property that is supposed to be sustaining it? And here's another: how many banks may go bust before the situation steadies? Goldman Sachs estimate the gap at $2trn; Professor Nouriel Roubini, of the Stern School of Business at New York University and a contemporary Nostradamus, says the number is $3trn. Any which way, it is large and the only way to save the US economy from a credit-crunch-induced recession is to try to narrow the gap by steadying property prices, while the banks are thrown a lifeline.
So far, the chief activist has been the U.S. central bank, the Federal Reserve, with the idea-lite Bush administration using the crisis to agree to tax cuts to stimulate the economy, its panacea for everything. It was the Fed that earlier last week agreed to offer $200bn of support that would have helped Bear Stearns; it was the Fed that bailed out Bear Stearns itself; and it was the Fed that earlier slashed interest rates. Chairman Ben Bernanke has said he will do everything in his power to prevent a rerun of 1929.
But the Fed cannot shoulder the entire burden itself. The U.S. government needs to put a floor under house prices by offering mortgage guarantees and prohibiting immediate foreclosures. Nor should the rest of the world stand idly by. The impact of the financial crisis is rocking the dollar; the EU, Japan, China and the oil exporters need to co-ordinate massive foreign exchange intervention.
The Europeans, and here Britain should take a lead, must redesign and reregulate their financial systems fast to close down the scope for the kind of seizure that has hit not just Bear Stearns, but British, German and French banks and threatens more. There must be a readiness to offer any troubled bank as much liquidity as it needs. This is not just an American, but global, emergency.
Above all, America's politicians, especially leading Democrats, need to stop blaming foreigners for America's problems while worshipping at the shrine of free finance. Instead, they need to nail the real culprits. On that the immediate future of the American -- and our economy -- depends.
(The Observer)